October 13th, 2004
如何教宝宝阅读
» motherhood
I am almost done with the Chinese translated copy of “How Teach Your Baby to Read” (《如何教宝宝阅读》). I skipped many sections as they are similar to what I have read in the teach math book. Almost wanted to put the book away, because I was quite irritated by what the editor (王宝星,not Doman) said in the preface. He said “现在已不是探讨是否「揠苗助长」、或怀疑「天才只有少数」的时候了,而是该担忧,过了三、五年后,如果每一个宝宝都成了超级天才,而我家的宝宝却不是,那该怎么办?” This is like threatening parents if they don’t teach their baby early, then their children will loose out. Every other kid will be a little genius, while their children will be the “simpleton”. And this fella is supposed to be some expert in early learning.
The teaching method for reading is identical to the teaching math method, flashing cards to babies at top speed, always introducing new materials, multiple short sessions etc. Babies are introduced noun first, especially those present in her surrounding, like people, fruits, furniture, animals, followed by verbs, then short phrases, sentences and finally books. Basically memory work.
Memory work, sounds dry and boring, how could it be fun to the kid? And are you sure the kid can remember? Well, I could remember most of the nursery rhythms and kiddy songs I learnt when I was young, but couldn’t remember the quotations from Macbeth or the important historical facts I tried to memorise painfully during my secondary school years. I have tried to memorised hundreds of Chinese poems during my high school years, but could only remember a few now. I am not buying the idea that the flash card method is fun though the author firmly thinks so. Though I believe memory work is vital in the initial stage of learning a language, I think there can be more enjoyable methods to disguise the memorising essence. Sing along or games will easily beat flash cards.
The book also addresses some of the parents’ worries.“太早学习阅读,对于一年级的课程不耐烦”, parents are worried that their early learners will be uninterested in the less challenging syallabus when they start school. To the author, this is entirely the problem of the teacher, or the education system, whom fail to excite the children, and is unable to cater to the needs of these “more knowledgeable” children. Well, there is definitely nothing wrong if the child happens to know more. It would be quite silly if we stop the child from learning to prevent the child from getting bored with the “less challenging” school work.
Another interesting point: parents are concerned that teaching young children too early is like robbing away their childhood,“让幼儿学习阅读,会剥夺他快乐的童年…..把宝宝关在婴儿床里,玩着不敢兴趣的玩具,或是任他声嘶力竭地叫闹,至少这样不会触电、割伤、打破东西、或是掉到窗子外面。这就是我们所谓宝贵的童年吗?” Again, he stressed that using the flash cards will provide endless happy learning experience to the baby, and also ensure bonding between the child and the parents. I am not sure if the flash cards sessions are really that thrilling, but certainly agree that putting the child in the cot or playpen or pram all the time is damaging. They really restrict their mobility and will probably kill their curiosity to explore.
Even if the kid is given a good head start, the other kids can easily catch up if they have a passion for learning, and they will be on par ultimately. As the Chinese saying goes小时了了,大未必佳, a good head start doesn’t guarantee a brighter future, the passion for learning still plays a bigger role. All parents wish for is that the kids be happy when they grow up, and too often, we associate happiness with academic achievements, thinking that it will ensure career success and a comfortable life.

Finally, almost finish reading “How To Teach Your Baby Math”. The author maintains that children, especially those between birth and four years, have unparalleled ability and desire for learning, but we adults have been keeping our children carefully isolated from it during this peak period of learning. He regrets that many adults only “keep the child clean, well fed, safe from the world about him and in a learning vacuum.” So since babies want to learn about everything, mathematics is something they want to learn too (babies are not choosy on what to learn), and to Glenn Doman, they can learn maths, and the younger they start, the easier it will be, and the better for their brains (more intelligent?).

